Tier List

Melvor Idle 2 Tier Lists

Skill priority rankings for Early Access progression.

Last updated:

Tier List Hub

How to use Melvor Idle 2 tier lists

Tier lists on this wiki rank priority, not permanent power. A skill can be S-tier for the first week because it unlocks multipliers, then drop in urgency once those bonuses are online. Early Access patches also move GP/hr and XP/hr, so treat rankings as decision aids you re-check after notes in the Updates Hub.

Start with the early skill priority list and the money making tier list, then cross-read Getting Started, Skills, and Progression.

What we rank

  • Early-game skill priority for new Steam accounts
  • Multiplier skills such as Astrology, Herblore, and Agility
  • Combat readiness versus pure GP skills
  • Mastery Guild value relative to raw levels

We do not rank pay-to-win items because Melvor Idle 2’s base game has no microtransactions. Soundtrack DLC is cosmetic audio and irrelevant to tiers.

S-tier thinking for Early Access

S-tier usually means “raises the speed of everything else.” That is why food (Cooking), Mastery task completion, Astrology, and Herblore appear high even when their direct GP/hr looks average. A B-tier money skill can still be correct for a short burst if it funds a shop upgrade that lifts an S-tier skill.

How rankings were built

Priorities synthesise official Early Access feature lists, developer comments on Astrology/Herblore/Agility, and common community guide consensus after launch week. When sources disagree, we favour permanent multipliers and quest readiness over brittle XP/hr screenshots.

Revisit this hub after major patches. A balance change to early money skills or potion tiers can reshuffle the middle of the list overnight.

Tier list philosophy for idle games

Idle RPGs punish fashion-meta thinking. The skill that looks strongest on a streamer’s day-seven account may be the wrong first click on your day-one save. Our lists emphasise unlock value, multiplier value, and failure cost. Cooking ranks high because running out of food fails combat. Astrology ranks high because every later hour inherits its bonuses. A flashy late combat skill can wait.

How to argue with the list

Disagreeing with a tier placement is healthy. Before you discard a recommendation, write down:

  1. What permanent bonus you gain by ignoring it
  2. What quest or Mastery task you delay
  3. What overnight idle becomes unsafe

If you still prefer a different order, customise freely — then measure results with Current Action rates for a full day.

Connecting tiers to other hubs

Maintenance promise

When Early Access ships a skill rework, we re-open this hub first. Mid-tier ranks move most often; S-tier multipliers move rarely unless Herblore or Astrology systems change.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers to the most common questions.

Is this Melvor Idle 2 tier list official?

No. It is an unofficial priority guide for Early Access planning.

Why is Herblore ranked so high?

Potions multiply other skills. Keeping Herblore current often saves more time than grinding a single base skill harder.

Do tier lists replace quests?

No. When Act requirements conflict with a tier pick, finish the quest need first — see Quests.